I didn't think Snagged would survive into Gothic, but Erik's Curiosa blessed me with some new cards, so I present the successor to Snagged, Dungeon! Many adjustments to come and you can see my introduction video here!

December 20, 2025

Removed

3 Autumn Unicorn
3 Estranged Loner
3 Guile Sirens
1 Ruler of Thul
2 Gloam Toads
1 Questing Beast
1 Kiss of Judas
2 Pond

Collection

1 Horrible Hybrids

Added

2 Acid Rain
4 Drowned
3 Order of the Sacred Oak
1 The Lady of the Lake
2 Failed Mutation
1 Bury
1 Ice Shards
2 Peculiar Port

Collection

1 Extinguish

This updated version of Dungeon went 3-1 in the Newport, Kentucky Cornerstone. Cutting the Gloam Toads really hurt my heart, but they just did not feel effective. Kiss of Judas was also a card I hated to cut, but every time the card came up, I hated seeing it as my draw. Cutting the Autumn Unicorns was a big change, but with site destruction lurking, I felt the Order of the Sacred Oak was a better option. The one change I may rescind is returning Ruler of Thul and removing Lady of Lake. I also felt that the Guile Sirens were overkill with Coy Nixie in the deck, and the Estranged Loner were cut for Drowned. I found that having an additional two drop, especially one that could hide submerged, was most helpful.

I did learn a lot at this event. Ward is far stronger than I ever imagined, and the Orders in this deck did a ton of work. The ward was able to protect an Order in my opponent's subsequent turn and then it would be primed to Meathook in the next turn. I was extremely disappointed with Lady of the Lake and I think Ruler of Thul would have been the better option. The Acid Rain were also very helpful, shutting down my options sites, particularly those that silenced my own defensive sites. I will say that I encountered one Savior with considerable warding, and so I may look into Silence effects to help remove them.

December 11, 2025

Removed

Fertile Earth
Pond

Added

Watery Grave
Mirror Realm

Somehow I forgot Mirror Realm, which can be another Thin Ice or Troll Bridge. Watery Grave could also be a nice token generator with the Thin Ice and Nixie/Siren combo. I was hesitant to remove a Fertile Earth, but it seemed like the best opponent among tough choices. The Pond was also a tough choice, but it feels less reliable with the increased Spellbook.

Decemeber 10, 2025

Removed

2 Root Spider
2 Failed Mutation
2 Order of the Sacred Oak
1 Deep Sea

Added

3 Order of the White Wing
3 Guile Sirens
1 Thin Ice

Bruce at Golden Eagle Cards tried my deck out and said that Thin Ice with Coy Nixie was incredibly powerful. So, I added a Thin Ice and opted to remove a Deep Sea since there is so much water threshold in the deck. I also decided to cut the Order of the Sacred Oak because even though I am terrified of site destruction, I think Necromancer and token hordes will be more prominent initially. I have also found that effectively getting Root Spiders into play can be difficult, so they were cut as well. Finally I removed the Failed Mutations. While they are an awesome card, there cost of 4 means that they cannot Meat Hook until turn five. In the place of these six cards I added three Order of the White Wing for anti-token and collection plays and 3 Guile Sirens to maximize Thin Ice. Guile Sirens is limited to only moving minions, but their three power means they can submerge on Thin Ice by luring in anything of 2 power or more, so they feel worth testing. I am also strongly considering getting more copies of Led Astray into the deck because of the power of Thin Ice.

Dungeon

@Lord_of_Itza